Talking about poetry boards makes me wonder what really would make a good one, if started today from scratch. For example, I prefer PFFA’s software to any other. I prefer Gaz’s former single forum for all poetry setup. I like a mix of newcomers and oldtimers, form and free. As few rules as possible. Many styles welcome. Discussion encouraged. Arguments allowed.
The closest thing to this currently is the Gaz. But there have been a lot of poets who have fled the Gaz over the years because of various political power plays and general goofiness. Other forums, though, simply don’t get the traffic, other than PFFA and Erato–and both of those forums have been damaged, perhaps irrevocably, by high-profile abuses of power.
In a previous comment, I mentioned to Howard that perhaps the status of the online poetry forum has reached its maturity. Perhaps it was a boom time and now things can settle into a slower period. Or perhaps it was a fad, and now things will simply die.
If all of the best and brightest from every board got together, I bet that something amazing could come of it. It might be nuclear war rather than a great poetry board, but it would still be amazing.