There’s a video on YouTube called “Kiwi!” that is devastatingly sad to me. Someone sent me a link to it a little earlier today asking if I had seen it. I had, but I wondered if I would still find it as moving as I did before. Just a few seconds in, I panicked and stopped the video. I remember how hard I cried the first time I saw it.
But I write about painful things all the time, things that are ground into my memory like dirt into a skinned knee. I can write about it. I can read other people’s poetry about the most heartbreaking events. I can. I do.
But I can’t watch an animated video about a determined kiwi.
Why? Am I just inured to my own brain’s awful images? Is there really a distance of words? Why are poems so often cathartic for me, but fiction isn’t?
Is it just the complexity of the poem, the density, the difficulty, the brevity, that makes it bearable, makes it activate almost a problem-solving portion of my brain rather than a purely experiential portion? Sad poetry is beautiful and healing. Sad movies just make me feel ill and depressed.
Am I alone?